In the Shadow of Du Bois
Afro-Modern Political Thought in America
By Robert Gooding-Williams
(Harvard University Press, Hardcover, 9780674035263, 350pp.)
Publication Date: September 2009
Other Editions of This Title: Paperback
"The Souls of Black Folk" is Du Bois's outstanding contribution to modern political theory. It is his still influential answer to the question, "What kind of politics should African Americans conduct to counter white supremacy?" Here, in a major addition to American studies and the first book-length philosophical treatment of Du Bois's thought, Robert Gooding-Williams examines the conceptual foundations of Du Bois's interpretation of black politics.
For Du Bois, writing in a segregated America, a politics capable of countering Jim Crow had to uplift the black masses while heeding the ethos of the black folk: it had to be a politics of modernizing "self-realization" that expressed a collective spiritual identity. Highlighting Du Bois's adaptations of Gustav Schmoller's social thought, the German debate over the "Geisteswissenschaften," and William Wordsworth's poetry, Gooding-Williams reconstructs "Souls'" defense of this "politics of expressive self-realization," and then examines it critically, bringing it into dialogue with the picture of African American politics that Frederick Douglass sketches in "My Bondage and My Freedom." Through a novel reading of Douglass, Gooding-Williams characterizes the limitations of Du Bois's thought and questions the authority it still exerts in ongoing debates about black leadership, black identity, and the black underclass. Coming to "Bondage" and then to these debates by looking backward and then forward from "Souls," Gooding-Williams lets "Souls" serve him as a productive hermeneutical lens for exploring Afro-Modern political thought in America.