I Sing for I Cannot Be Silent (Paperback)

The Feminization of American Hymnody, 1870–1920 (Composition, Literacy, and Culture)

By June Hadden Hobbs

University of Pittsburgh Press, 9780822956389, 232pp.

Publication Date: October 15, 1997

List Price: 32.95*
* Individual store prices may vary.


Evangelical churches sing hymns written between 1870 and 1920 so often that many children learn them by rote before they are able to read religious texts. A cherished part of communal Christian life and an important and effective way to teach doctrine today, these hymns served an additional social purpose in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: they gave evangelical women a voice in their churches.
When the sacred music business expanded after the Civil War, writing hymn texts gave publishing opportunities to women who were forbidden to preach, teach, or pray aloud in mixed groups. Authorized by oral expression, gospel hymns allowed women to articulate alternative spiritual models within churches that highly valued orality.

These feminized hymns are the focus of "I Sing for I Cannot Be Silent." Drawing upon her own experience as a Baptist, June Hadden Hobbs argues that the evangelical tradition is an oral tradition--it is not anti-intellectual but antiprint. Evangelicals rely on memory and spontaneous oral improvisation; hymns serve to aid memory and permit interaction between oral and written language. 

By comparing male and female hymnists' use of rhetorical forms, Hobbs shows how women utilized the only oral communication allowed to them in public worship. Gospel hymns permitted women to use a complex system of images already associated with women and domesticity.  This feminized hymnody challenged the androcentric value system of evangelical Christianity by making visible the contrasting masculine and feminine versions of Christianity. When these hymns were sung in church, women's voices and opinions moved out of the private sphere and into public religion. The hymns are so powerful that they are suppressed by some contemporary fundamentalists today.

In "I Sing for I Cannot Be Silent" June Hadden Hobbs employs an interdisciplinary mix of feminist literary analysis, social history, rhetoric and composition theory, hymnology, autobiography, and theology to examine hymns central to worship in most evangelical churches today.

About the Author

June Hadden Hobbs grew up in Wynnewood, Oklahoma, where she often accompanied hymns on the piano at First Baptist Church. She is department chair and professor of English at Gardner-Webb University.

Praise For I Sing for I Cannot Be Silent: The Feminization of American Hymnody, 1870–1920 (Composition, Literacy, and Culture)

“Hobbs’s book should certainly alert religious historians to the rich interpretive possibilities of American hymnody, but also to the need for further exploration of the larger social world that made them such enduring and significant features of the religious landscape.”
—The Journal of American History

“Building in part on her own childhood memories, Hobbs writes about the important role gospel hymns have played in the evangelical community. She focuses on the period between 1870 and 1920 but more briefly discusses earlier and later periods as well. Hobbs in particularly interested in women hymn writers and the position of power that hymn-writing gave to women. She argues that before the civil war, hymns were primarily used in private meditation and were the cultural property of women. After 1870, however, as hymns were used more frequently in public worship, women had less control over them. To make her case, Hobbs evaluates the use of hymns in domestic novels and compares hymns written by male and female hymnists. Hobb’s work gives evidence of much research and applies theories from a number of disciplines.”