Shadows in the Asylum
The Case Files of Dr. Charles Marsh
Clerisy Press, 9781578602049, 216pp.
Publication Date: December 28, 2005
Conversation Starters from ReadingGroupChoices.com
Do you believe in the supernatural? Did reading this book change any of your beliefs? If so, how?
Do you think science will eventually find an explanation for every inexplicable/supernatural phenomenon?
Discuss how Kari Hansen was treated as a patient by the doctors at Kriegmoor. Consider, in particular, her treatment by Dr. Marsh versus her treatment by Dr. Ferguson. Contrast with your own experiences, either as a patient or, as in the case of Kari’s mother, as a member of the family or friend of a patient.
Do you think the creatures Dr. Marsh encountered were real or his imagination?
How do you feel about the death penalty? Does the possibility that there is an afterlife influence those feelings?
Did you like experiencing the story through the mechanism of ‘found documents,’ as opposed to a traditional text narrative? What was good/bad about this storytelling method? What do you see as its strengths/weaknesses?
How do you feel about religion? Do you see it as Dr. Marsh did, as an attempt by primitive man to explain aspects of the natural world he could not understand?
What is the single action you’ve taken in your life you feel most guilty about?
Are there places you’ve visited that carried a foreboding feeling, as if previous generations somehow still had an influence or control?
Considering the various ways that characters were “opened up” to see the shadows—by illness, isolation, drugs—do you believe there are parts of our senses rationally closed off to other phenomena in life? If so, what else do you think is out there?
For earlier or indigenous civilizations not based in current religious beliefs, do you think the culture and practices and vengeances of these peoples still affect our world?
If there are spirits among us, vestiges of people and willful actions from long ago, do you think we can change or communicate with them?